Showing 17–32 of 44 results

Pretzel Bitz and Chocolate Chip Stuffed Caramel cookie

#13 Pretzel Bitz and Chocolate Chip Stuffed Caramel

$4.00 – $96.00

Pretzel Bitz

Select options
Double Dark Rocky Road – Chocolate Chips, Marshmallow and Walnut cookie

#14 Double Dark Rocky Road – Chocolate Chips, Marshmallow and Walnut

$4.50 – $108.00

Double Dark Rocky Road

Select options
Chocolate Chip Nutella Bowl cookie

#15 Chocolate Chip Nutella Bowl

$4.50 – $108.00

Nutella Bowl

Select options
Chocolate Chip Chunky Peanut Butter Bowl cookie

#16 Chocolate Chip Chunky Peanut Butter Bowl

$4.50 – $108.00

Chocolate Chip Peanut Butter Bowl

Select options
Chocolate Chip Dolce De Lèche Bowl cookie

#17 Chocolate Chip Dolce De Lèche Bowl

$4.50 – $108.00

Chocolate Chip with Dolce De Leche Dolloped and Exposed in the Center

Select options
M&M’s n Oreo cookie

#18 M&M’s n Oreo

$4.50 – $108.00

M&M n Oreo

Select options

#19 M&M’s

$4.00 – $96.00

Smores

Select options
S’mores – Graham Crackers, Choc Chips and Marshmallows cookie

#20 S’mores – Graham Crackers, Choc Chips and Marshmallows

$4.50 – $108.00

The Famous Chocolate Chip Smore.  This Cookie is Loaded with Chocolate Chips, Crushed Grahm Cracker Crumbs and Chunks with Marshmallows. Graham Crackers, Choc Chunks and Marshmallows. You will feel like…

Select options
Fun Fetti cookie

#21 Fun Fetti

$4.00 – $96.00

This cookie is packed with sugar sprinkles and stuffed with mini marshmallows in the center of this fun treat. This super fun cookie is a an explosion of colorful sprinkles…

Select options
Fruity Pebbles Stuffed Milk cookie

#22 Fruity Pebbles Stuffed Milk

$4.00 – $96.00

Fruity Pebbles is all around and in this outrageous cookie and centered with a milky marshmallow marinade. This combination of Aunt Lullie’s delicious cookie dough with Fruity Pebble cereal is…

Select options
PB&J – Peanut Butter and Jelly cookie

#23 PB&J – Peanut Butter and Jelly

$4.50 – $108.00

Peanut Butter Chip Cookie with Four Berry Jelly and Peanut Butter Stuffed inside of this delight Peanut Butter Chips and Four Berry Jelly – This cookie is one of Aunt…

Select options

#24 Chocolate Macadamia Nut

$4.50 – $108.00

This Chocolate Chip Macadamia Nut will fill those nut lover cravings!

Select options

#25 Chocolate Macadamia Coconut

$4.50 – $108.00

Take an Aunt Lullie chocolate chip macadamia nut cookie and add some coconut. The result will make you want to do a little dance when you take your first bite.…

Select options
Apple Strudel cookie

#26 Apple Strudel

$4.50 – $108.00

This Apple Pie Cookie will not disappoint! Apple Stuffed Cookie with Crushed Grams and Special Sauce-Soaked Raisins Is it a cookie? Is it a strudel? It’s both!! Aunt Lullie takes…

Select options
Snicker Doodle Stuffed Caramel cookie

#27 Snicker Doodle Stuffed Caramel

$4.00 – $96.00

Cinnamin Rolled Cookie Dough stuffed with a load of smooth soft Caramel This Snickerdoodle is nothing to snicker at. Aunt Lullie’s original vanilla cookie batter gets rolled around in a…

Select options

#28 Reese’s Smasher Mini Cup

$4.50 – $108.00

Another one of Aunt Lullie’s best sellers. We use big peanut butter cups, small peanut butter cups and smashed peanut butter cups. It’s almost ridiculous! Ridiculous how much you will…

Select options

Product Categories